| 1 |  | Once in Royal David's City |  | 4:27 | 
  | 2 |  | O Come, All Ye Faithful (Adeste fidelis) |  | 4:02 | 
  | 3 |  | Hark! the Herald Angels Sing (adapted by W. H. Cummings from Mendelssohn's Festgesang for the Gutenberg Festival) |  | 3:06 | 
  | 4 |  | In the Bleak Midwinter |  | 4:19 | 
  | 5 |  | The First Nowell (English) |  | 4:57 | 
  | 6 |  | O Little Town of Bethlehem |  | 3:19 | 
  | 7 |  | In dulci jubilo (Piæ Cantiones) |  | 3:39 | 
  | 8 |  | A Great and Mighty Wonder |  | 3:10 | 
  | 9 |  | Unto Us Is Born A Son (Puer nobis nascitur; Piae Cantiones, 1582) |  | 1:55 | 
  | 10 |  | Sussex Carol ("On Christmas Night") |  | 1:54 | 
  | 11 |  | Do You Hear What I Hear? |  | 3:56 | 
  | 12 |  | While Shepherds Watched Their Flocks By Night (unspecified tune) |  | 3:12 | 
  | 13 |  | Away in a manger (Tune: Cradle Song) (New English Hymnal 22) |  | 1:59 | 
  | 14 |  | Ding Dong! Merrily on High (French) |  | 1:59 | 
  | 15 |  | The Holly and the Ivy (English) |  | 2:41 | 
  | 16 |  | Up! Good Christian Folk, and Listen (Piae cantiones) |  | 1:18 | 
  | 17 |  | Coventry Carol (2): "Lully, Lulla, Thou Little Tiny Child" |  | 2:12 | 
  | 18 |  | God Rest You Merry, Gentlemen (English) |  | 3:30 | 
  | 19 |  | I Saw Three Ships |  | 1:34 | 
  | 20 |  | King Jesus Hath A Garden (Dutch) |  | 3:58 | 
  | 21 |  | See amid the winter's snow |  | 3:56 | 
  | 22 |  | Rocking Carol (Czech) |  | 1:39 | 
  | 23 |  | Shepherds in the Field Abiding |  | 3:02 | 
  | 24 |  | The infant King (Basque) |  | 3:13 | 
  | 25 |  | Stille Nacht, heilige Nacht (Silent Night) |  | 2:33 |